However, it visualizes what areas we think are the most and least inbred, based on these regions' histories and other pieces of evidence we have. Locus refers to the location of a gene on the chromosome and an allele is a . (The high immigrant populations in the ex-Soviet states are mostly Russians; those in Ireland are primarily from Britain. more on albanians, Scandinavia: As such, according to HBD Chicks hypothesis, the region went down a unique historical trajectory because of it. Pakistan and Israel having nuclear weapons is already bad enough. I dont think White Americas conservative future will provoke Armageddon. ), but in nineteenth century alsace-lorraine, the cousin marriage rate for jews was only 2.3% (compared to ca. Generally, inbreeding is more common in the southeast region of the U.S. and more rural states. Genetic bottlenecks and inbreeding can increase the frequency of deleterious variants, resulting in reduced reproductive levels in a population. America is noteworthy, but they have relatively lower rates of inbreeding from 0.1 to 0.2% of the population. Like some places in Africa where pygmies live with bantu people in some countries their average height wouldnt tell us much about the actual situation. Outbred liberals seem to think everyone is the same and we can all live together in harmony if only were all taught perfect puritan manners (i.e. Also, as HBD Chick noted, the fairly high levels of civicness found in Blacks may be titled towards exclusive, self/in-group interested forms rather than the truly exclusive, out-group oriented ones seen in NW Euros see: good civicness vs. bad civicness | hbd* chick ). Historically, I dont think there was a lot of internal movement in Japan, due to a pretty dictatorial state, which would tend to increase inbreeding, but that same dictatorial state really cut down on violence. Buckhead Moves Forward with Plan to Secede from Atlanta. With Stossel on Fox Im thinking weve already got a relatively inbred audience so itll only compound the problem. russians, eastern europeans, runs of homozygosity (roh), and inbreeding These divisions (with some exceptions which soon Ill note) shouldnt be taken to be hard and fast. My guesses: Iceland is most inbred because the population is smaller. PeriStats is the online database for perinatal statistics developed by the March of Dimes Perinatal Data Center. Genes seem to assert themselves more with age. These divisions have had great significance for the past and present of these countries and the countries they sired. At that level, you get most of the advantages of outbreeding, including liberal democracy, functional institutions, and a high-trust society, but retain a certain level of nationalism and ethnic cohesion that allows the society to resist opening itself to non-reciprocating outsiders, as the most outbred Northwestern Europeans apparently have. Time for another humiliating failure for the fading American empire, Truth About Tanks: How NATO Lied Its Way to Disaster in Ukraine, The Crisis in Ukraine is not about Ukraine. Inbreeding is surprisingly common in many Muslim nations and communities, evidence shows. Tips For Efficiency: Worldly Repository of Knowledge, The U.S has a low inbreeding rate of about 0.1 to 0.2% only, There are only 18 states listed to have inbreeding cases, West Virginia and Kentucky are the most prominent states that have inbreeding cases. Chances of muscular atrophy are 18x higher. What Accounts for the Continuation of Homosexuality? These divisions have had great significance for the past and present of these countries, Ralph and Coop also discussed these data in, The average IBD rates for each of the countries sampled is shown. Nice, cant see the first map though, maybe its my browser or something. Washington, Oregon, Montana, South Dakota, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana, Indiana, Tennessee, Alabama, Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina, Virginia, Maryland, Delaware, and Maine. Swedes are individualistic in the sense that they do feel any particularly family loyalty, but at the same time, like the Japanese (lots of similarities between Scandis/Finns and Japanese), they go with the flow of the group. Our family has been researching ourselves for decades because were very diverse and when I married my husband I made it much more diverse. The best-known inbred family in Eastern Kentucky is the Fugate family, The Whitakers are the most famous Inbred family in America. Is that Ottoman influence, or what? While Sweden and Japan may display low levels of cousin marriages, they are isolated and like Amber pointed out, this means that everyone is fairly related after a while. @simon For instance the guestimate map of inbreeding seems to not explain why Scandinavians are known for genetic disorders like Haemochromatosis and Huntingtons diseases. Secondly, theres this map of the perceived corruption across Europe (from Transparency Internationals 2012 Corruption Perceptions Index), which produces a striking pattern: And now, here are a collection of posts detailing data on mating patterns from these various countries (from HBD Chick except where otherwise noted). North Africa, the Middle East, Central South Asia populations have the highest rate of consanguinity than the rest of the world. As HBD Chick discusses, the disappearance of references to Germanic kindreds (the Germanic version of the clan, see medieval germanic kindreds and the ditmarsians | hbd* chick and more on medieval germanic kindreds | hbd* chick) also follows this pattern: (In that post ibd rates and kindreds in germanic populations HBD Chick also examines the samples used in Ralphs and Coops analysis. Homicide Map four: Firearms offences My personal experience with Jews is that they are not quite as clannish as they claim. They have no cars, no . This similarity could signal several things, including a recent population bottleneck or historically small population size (both of which would tend to minimize genetic diversity within the population), or few admixture events in the populations history. This is higher than the reported figure in a national sample of non-Bedouin Arabs ( F = 0.192) (Jaber et al. Are COVID VaccinesLike COVID Itselfa "Pentagon Project"? As said in the post, the guestimate isnt without basis in the evidence. It dropped by 18% in the 1970s, then plateaud in the 1930s. consanguinity in england north vs. south parented and schooled correctly to accept everyone for who they are) It never seems to cross their minds that their children are accepting, because the parents are, not because theyre taught to be. Widespread inbreeding in Saudi Arabia has produced several genetic disorders, Saudi public health officials said, including the blood diseases of thalassemia, a potentially fatal hemoglobin. Sometimes I wonder if the Japanese just mentally transferred their clan loyalties straight to the state. more on medieval england and france That would seem to fit into HBD Chicks commonweal orientation. 3 or 4 the irish But not all inbreeding is the same. Use of multiple, non-Anonymous handles for commenting on this webzine is strongly discouraged, and your secret (real or fictitious) email allows you to authenticate your commenter-identity, preventing others from assuming it, accidentally or otherwise. Also, its worth noting that historic rates of inbreeding are just one selective force among many (not the least of which being the effects of manorialism, of strong states, and of internal population replacement ala Gregory Clark/Ron Unz) which act on a population (which may act synergistically to produce the traits we see), and close analysis may not reveal a perfect association between modern clannishness and historical rates of inbreeding, perhaps due to the vagaries of other selective forces that have been acting on these populations. The polygamous town facing genetic disaster. Quite possibly. Inbreeding in the United States of America is legal in 19 states, allowing first-cousin marriages. Razib Khan has two posts on that: 54% of Muslims in the United Arab Emirates and Qatar are inbred. InductivistA blog of short, data-driven posts. See (from HBD chick), (As well, many might note that HBD Chicks analysis generally doesnt focus on sub-Saharan Africa much. These are general ideas based on the evidence I have so far seen. Genetic Disorders Hit Amish Hard. Washington Egged on by Its Neoconservatives Has Concluded That Putin Has No Stomach for War Beyond a Limited Police Action, Little Uruguay: Big Scholastic Expectations. In general, mating between people who are closer than first cousins is considered inbreeding. In 1967, when miscegenation laws were overturned in the United States, 3% of all newlyweds were married to someone of a different race or ethnicity. The Occidentalist Analyzes data on IQ and facets of human psychology. The mean inbreeding coefficient (F) in the present study was 0.0238. The selective pressures in these inbred societies were different, hence they retain a different set of behavioral traits. Many Muslim countries have low murder rates but when people from these countries emigrate to more free countries they become very violent and account for a lot of the murders in their new countries. kinship in anglo-saxon society ii These divisions (with some exceptions which soon Ill note) shouldnt be taken to be hard and fast. The place with the second most was actually Kent, with 58. absolutely! As such, according to HBD Chicks hypothesis, the region. However, the genetic data we have analyzed so far does support HBD Chicks hypothesis. Alien perspectives cant hurt. I think a key question is whether the population is merely all closely related, or fractured into distinct clans who are even more closely related to each other than everyone in the population is related. Also, see what HBD Chick said . Their parents have died, who are believed to be closely related genetically and biologically. As the years go by, people have realized the danger of inbreeding amongst humans 34,000 years ago and developed social norms. 2008 ). This has been shown by numerous studies with cattle, horses, sheep, swine and laboratory animals. My hat is off to you, this post is now my go-to reference on the subject. This is a map of our current best guess of the rates of historic inbreeding across Europe and parts of the Near East. This map is a guestimate, and is not derived from direct measurements. Inbreeding is common in the southeast region and more rural states, such as Eastern Kentucky. http://www.researchgate.net/publication/215555434_MHC-heterozygosity_and_human_facial_attractiveness Several countries started banning the practice from 1858 to 1960, including Kansas, Nevada, North Dakota, South Dakota, Washington, New Hampshire, Ohio, and Wyoming. Inbreeding generally increases prereproductive mortality; crude mortality increases with inbreeding in proportion to the mortality rate. Estimates show that nearly half of those living in the Arab world are inbred. In short, people in these countries expect their transgressions to be met with violent retribution. To me both perspectives are foolish in their own ways. Even though inbreeding might not be as common today, it may have been more common in the past, which has contributed to lots of people being very genetically similar. I think that type of conformism is an on a separate dimension from individualism vs. clannishness as HBD Chick would describe it. This would be fine advice, if it were appearing on a liberal channel, maybe Colbert or Maddow Those people could use a little inbreeding here and there. Its like the key bit from the post, man! early and late medieval irish mating practices It is impossible to be certain what direction the band will take next. Ukraine is Sinking. more on consanguinity in england (and scotland) in early Medieval times. I think you may have hit the nail on the head. educationrealist One teachers look at the from the inside of the cognitive-ability-denying world of American education. Go ahead he said marry your cousin its alright. Did a Chinese Lab-Leak Kill Twenty Million People? you might also want to check all my other posts on the history of mating patterns in various other populations (see left-hand column toward the bottom of the page on my blog). But not all inbreeding is the same. HBD Fundamentals: On the evolution of modern advanced civilized peoples, Also see this brand new post at Staffans Personality Blog: The Clannish World of Organized Crime, Edit 3/13/14: See also big summary post on the hajnal line | hbd* chick. My guesses: Iceland is most inbred because the population is smaller. It is subject to revision, and will probably continue to be updated as I gather more evidence. In humans, it's associated with consanguinity and incest, in which close relatives have sexual relationships and children. inbreeding in 18th and 19th century sweden Inbreeding is the process of mating genetically similar organisms. Read some history and genetics for a f* sake. See a map of your community and any neighborhood-level data on community-safety from users. It is often associated with consanguinity and incest. As we can see, my map is in very good agreement with Ralphs and Coops data, particularly the pronounced divide between Western and Eastern Europe, as well as the regional variation across the British Isles. But it is one factor among many in shaping the selective forces acting upon a people. The eastern mountain people of Kentucky are called the Appalachians. Even though they mostly dont marry first or second cousins, they do end up marrying third and fourth cousins a lot, because everyone there is related at that level. Mine is just one other point of view, though one that feels alien to almost everyone. Id be remiss to not mention the effect of geography, climate, and topography on this (from Wikipedia): Mountains may contribute to inbreeding by making both farming and long-range travel difficult (favoring a pastoral way of life) see the flatlanders vs. the mountain people | hbd* chick. Map three: Homicide The number of homicides - murders and manslaughters - was roughly proportionate to the size of population across the country. Its about whether or not the total population is sub-divided into thousands of mini populations who marry their own close cousins. On the other hand, being someone in the middle ground doesnt necessarily give me a correct understanding of the situation. The lines on the map were drawn by me. The highest inbreeding levels and frequencies of inbred individuals are in North Africa, the Middle East, Central South Asia population. In a recent report in DW by S Khan, the author discussed how Pakistan is facing many medical challenges due to the high rate of cousin marriages. Now indeed, to place HBD-Chicks hypothesis on the most solid footing, we should ideally examine the genetic data to get firmer estimates of the level of long-term inbreeding in these populations, rather than relying primarily on historical data and the traits of modern peoples. Physical Issues. my scandinavian history is more than a little fuzzy can never keep track of when the kalmar and other unions were! thank you for your thought provoking (hard!) My guess is that they may be inbred but not necessarily clannish. An imported dog will obtain a . This pattern also follows the spread of Christianity, as seen on this map featured over at Dusk in Autumn: As may be obvious from my map of inbreeding in Europe at the beginning of the post, it appears (we believe) that outbreeding originated in the area around Northeastern France/the Low Countries and Southern England and spread outward from there in all directions. Horses produce only one foal from an eleven-month gestation period, making the maintenance of high reproductive rates essential. I dont mean that you will find a shicksa in every family tree. Finally, there are some genetic disorders that are more common among Hasidic and Haredi Jewish groups because they tend to marry members of the same population as well. At the very least, the average Dutch person has historically moved around more than the average Russianthe Dutch had colonies in the US, Africa, India, and Indonesiawhereas the average Russian peasant was tied to their land and would have married locally. This is an undertaking we might pursue in the manner Razib Khan suggested, and this might be a project we will soon address. How are humans inbred? American Pravda: World War III and World War II? That is not to say that mountain-dwelling always results in inbreeding; as we saw, the denizens of the Alps managed to avoid it. As we can see, several countries are significantly divided regionally. Thus, many of the Fugates began to marry their family members. for instance, it seems that jews on mallorca right up until the 20th century married within their clans (although im not sure what, exactly, that means), and cousin marriage was reportedly common amongst jews in nineteenth century russia (how common, who knows? One of these was that it was somehow bad to marry your cousin. I mean, if everyone loves gay people, thats not individualism. As well, supporting the notion that some European countries possess distinct regional variation within them in how inbred their populations are, we have these pieces: For Britain (from traditional family systems in medieval britain and ireland | hbd* chick): And Spain (from here and here, respectively): Reinforcing the pattern we see across Europe and much of the world are the results of the Worlds Values Survey: The Northwestern European countries are in a group by themselves. Mountains, and presumably a closely related group of people to begin with. So maybe we should look at islanders. what about the franks? The current idea is that a type of de facto inbreeding existed there thanks to sub-Saharan Africas high rates of polygyny: see monogamy, serial monogamy, and polygamy | hbd* chick. Keep in mind that Ashkenazi Jews are all descended from European shicksas. A beast in a cage is still a beast, to put it politically incorrect. Bank Runs, Bail-Ins and Systemic Risk. Among Israeli Ashkenazi Jews, the first-cousin marriage rate was measured in a 1955-7 study at 1.4% and other cousin marriages at 1.06% of all marriages. As per HBD Chicks hypothesis, the Islamic countries which are the most inbred of them all cluster on an opposite pole to the Northwestern European ones. It continuedly decreased until today. jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/judaica/ejud_0002_0007_0_07175.html. We explored the relationships between inbreeding, morphology and health using genotype based inbreeding estimates, body weight and insurance data for morbidity. As we can see, several countries are significantly divided regionally. Read some history and genetics for a f* sake. (im trying not to invoke the old GIGO computer trope for inbreeding pygmies:) i.e., do you think the relationship between level of inbreeding & whatever dependent variable is the same for all groups? There are also certain groups of people who live in cloistered societies, meaning they are not exposed to the outside world. June 8, 2005 / 4:28 PM / CBS. Similarly, the pattern of marriages with paternal and maternal first cousins decreased during the period from 1990 to 2013, nonetheless, slightly increased in 2017-2018. Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone. Research in the Boyko Lab has shown that a 10% increase in inbreeding can lead to a 6% reduction in adult size (poor growth) and a six- to ten-month reduction in lifespan. clannish medieval ireland Their father is from the Netherlands. They divide the areas of historic outbreeding from the areas that have long-term inbreeders (based on data supplied by HBD Chick, which will be reviewed shortly), which is roughly coterminous with the, Secondly, theres this map of the perceived corruption across Europe (from, There are several historical correlates with this pattern. early modern and modern clannish ireland On the other hand, inbreeding in the animal population can also be used to increase the prevalence of a favorable trade in that speciess population. Further reinforcing our estimation of historic levels of inbreeding across various parts of Europe and the Middle East, as seen on my map, is the fact that many of these countries (the Islamic world) are still actively inbreeding (from consang.net): Europeans and for that matter East Asians have, by in large, ceased inbreeding in the 20th century by the latest. In the United States Birth defects affect one in every 33 babies (about 3% of all babies) born in the United States each year. 11 the arabs. I get the feeling research is being cherry picked for articles/data supporting someones pet theses. They divide the areas of historic outbreeding from the areas that have long-term inbreeders (based on data supplied by HBD Chick, which will be reviewed shortly), which is roughly coterminous with the Hajnal line. What is the most inbred country? kinship in anglo-saxon society Assuming continued bifurcation of the US population is a problem, which Im not sure it is. meanwhile, in ireland Why Hasn't Evolution Weeded Out the 'Gay Gene'? Indeed. Thats not the conclusion these sources reach. It could be a problem for some, namely those living in the borderland areas (such as myself) where the fighting typically takes place were we to see a balkanization of the US. (^_^) (i will have to take a closer look at it during the week, though. Human inbreeding is the act of mating between two closely related people, including relatives, parents, or siblings. and some of the surrounding, environmental selection pressures may give different results, too. Im beginning to suspect that different kinds of inbreeding create different behaviors. Which country is the most inbred? 7-8 the albanians This is the real money question, We know arranged marriages between cousins was the norm until at least the late 1800s, It was common wisdom in the Jewish community that you dont marry for love you marry to create intelligent, competitive offspring, Very interesting how the elite media and Hollywood has pushed for years the so-called backwardness of inbreeding. The Tablet: Whiteness Ends, Jews Hardest Hit, The Not So Great Reset: Lowering Standards, Parts 312 and 313, An Essential Difference Between Liberals and Conservatives, AP: Covid Caused Turmoil in Chicago That Cost Mayor Lightfoot Re-Election. Italy: Sardinia is VERY inbred [Corsica also]. Also see this brand new post at Staffans Personality Blog: https://www.unz.com/jman/how-inbred-are-europeans/, The Unz Review An Alternative Media Selection, went down a unique historical trajectory because of it, Razib Khan recently objected to HBD Chick, Transparency Internationals 2012 Corruption Perceptions Index, HBD Chicks european consanguinity bibliography, consanguinity in england north vs. south, more on consanguinity in england (and scotland), cousin marriage in 13th-15th century england, mating patterns in medieval/early modern scotland, early and late medieval irish mating practices, mating patterns, family types, and clannishness in twentieth century ireland, runs of homozygosity in the irish population, more on mating patterns from deutschland (and switzerland), feuds, tournaments, and reproductive success in medieval germany (franconia), exogamous marriage in northern medieval italy, mating patterns in medieval eastern europe, traditional family systems in medieval russia, russians, eastern europeans, runs of homozygosity (roh), and inbreeding, inbreeding in 18th and 19th century sweden, medieval germanic kindreds and the ditmarsians | hbd* chick, more on medieval germanic kindreds | hbd* chick, ibd rates and kindreds in germanic populations, historic european homicide rates and the hajnal line, traditional family systems in medieval britain and ireland, national individualism-collectivism scores, fairly unique pathologies found in the Muslim world, Those Who Can See: Arabs and Liberal Democracy: A Primer, abridged history of cousin marriage in china, see monogamy, serial monogamy, and polygamy | hbd* chick, see: good civicness vs. bad civicness | hbd* chick, the least of which being the effects of manorialism, of strong states, and of internal population replacement ala Gregory Clark/Ron Unz, the flatlanders vs. the mountain people | hbd* chick, big summary post on the hajnal line | hbd* chick, 100 Blog Posts - A Reflection on HBD Blogging and What Lies Ahead, An HBD Summary of the Foundations of Modern Civilization, American Pravda: Of Pipelines and Plagues, Clannishness the Series: Zigzag Lightning in the Brain, Ashkenazi Jews are not inbred Gene Expression, Ashkenazi Jews are not inbred 2 Gene Expression |, HBD: An Abbreviated History of Quisqueya and the Rise of Todays Dominicans (and Haitians) :: Concourse Expressions, http://www.researchgate.net/publication/215555434_MHC-heterozygosity_and_human_facial_attractiveness, http://ndt.oxfordjournals.org/content/15/9/1269.full, Greg Cochrans and Paul Ewalds paper on pathogens, Greg Cochran's "Gay Germ" Hypothesis - An Exercise in the Power of Germs, The Problem with HBD, the Dark Enlightenment, Neoreaction, Alt-Rightism, and All That Jazz, No, You Don't Have Free Will, and This Is Why, Mike's Antivax Grab-Bag: Memes, Blurbs and Links, Americas Buried History of White Slavery, "Why the Lab Leak Theory Is Almost Certainly False", The Alt-Covid Community Begins Unraveling the Origins of Covid, American Pravda: George Orwell's Virus Lab-Leak, Coerced by Declining American Empire, Kenyan Court Tries to Force People to Do Sodomy on Each Other, A Sign of Things to Come? Afrikaner genomics. In humans, it's the process of reproducing with your close relatives. 6-7 the italians, the greeks, the chinese I checked the map from a different IP, it does work, so maybe you want to try reloading it. Inbreeding was highest in the Washington Cascades (15 percent), lowest in western Oregon (3.5 percent) and northern California (2.7 percent), and intermediate for the Olympic Peninsula of Washington . Perhaps Slovenia, a bit of a paradox here, can also be a case of smooth inbreeding but of a higher degree than Sweden and Japan. A new method for estimating inbreeding rates over an extended period of time and for large regions, such as entire countries or groups of countries, based on the solution of the genealogical 'paradox', has recently been reported by Pattison, 1999, Pattison, 2001, Pattison, 2003. "US Presidential Candidate" Vivek Ramaswamy Says "America First 2.0" Needs to be About War with China, Vloggerdormodo (NOT Vladimir) Zelensky Threatens Americans Who Dont Support His Endless War, Berlin: Tens of Thousands Rally Against Ukraine War, NATO, Greetings from Oujda, Morocco, the City of Mosques, J. Michael Springmann on What He Saw in Iran, John Carter (Postcards from Barsoom) on Gender Wars. (on Iceland) random notes: 09/06/13 F or example, if the average inbreeding level in a population is 0.23, and it was 0.21 in the previous generation, then the rate of inbreeding is (0.23 - 0.21) / (1 - 0.21) = 0.0253. Commenting Disabled While in Translation Mode, xxAnonFromTN|xxAnonStarter|xxNicols Palacios Navarro|xxL.K|xxRes|xxSolontoCroesus|xxTalha|xxxErebus|xxMark Green|xxAP, HBD Chick and I talk about how rates of historic inbreeding have had an important impact on the selective pressures acting on the traits of various peoples living today. Ashkenazim are a relatively homogeneous group despite their settlement in different European countries for centuries. but the point is different genetic material is being inbred into each system so, different inputs (even with the same catalyzing inbreeding pattern/formula) may yield different results? http://ndt.oxfordjournals.org/content/15/9/1269.full. Who is the most inbred person in America? On the other hand weve got the more inbred folks who are family focused, patriotic, but somehow also hate the government for anything it does that isnt about defending the borders and teaching other groups whos boss. They have a large (albeit, historically isolated) population, so perhaps that help to selection out clannishness? Notwithstanding, this is quite an informative post! It just doesnt look like a mild form of clannishness. The reported prevalence of consanguinity in Arab and Middle-East Countries were vary between 35-40% with the 99% confidence interval for 3% error of estimation, a sample size of 1626 subjects would be required for this study to achieve objective. What does inbred mean for humans? Many famous personalities in the 18th and 19th century are inbred. 63% of Sudanese are inbred. And indeed, perhaps this was the case. Its not about the total population. For example, a population of 40 adders (Vipera berus, shown at right) experienced inbreeding depression when farming activities in Sweden isolated them from other adder populations. Indeed, HBD Chick hypothesized that the manor system contributed to the breakdown of the clans and made cousin marriage considerably more difficult.